Cumberland Local Planning Panel Meeting
10 March 2021
Minutes of the Electronic
Cumberland Local Planning Panel Meeting held via Zoom on Wednesday 10 March
2021.
Present:
The Hon. Paul Stein AM QC(Chairperson), Marjorie Ferguson,
Michael Ryan and Allan Ezzy AM APM.
In Attendance:
Jai Shankar, Olivia Yana, Stephen Peterson, Diep Hang,
Elizabeth Chan, Michael Lawani, Esra Calim, Olivia Shields, Monica Shenouda,
Paulette Maroon and Rashika Rani.
The meeting here opened at 11:33a.m.
Declarations Of Interest:
There were no declarations of
interest.
ADDRESS BY INVITED SPEAKERS:
The following persons had made
application to address the Cumberland Local Planning Panel meeting:
Speakers Item
No. Subject
Natalie Sultana Development
Application for 40-42 Ettalong Road, Greystanes
Richard Attard Development
Application for 40-42 Ettalong Road, Greystanes
Ram Baskaran Development
Application for 40-42 Ettalong Road, Greystanes
Jonathon Wood Development
Application for 40-42 Ettalong Road, Greystanes
Matthew Elyard Development
Application for 40-42 Ettalong Road, Greystanes
Faydi Saddik Development
Application for 67 Pegler Avenue, South Granville
Craig McGaffin Development
Application for 67 Pegler Avenue, South Granville
Perry Savidis Development
Application for 67 Pegler Avenue, South Granville
Rod Zoabi Development
Application for 67 Pegler Avenue, South Granville
Adrian Mason Modification
Application for 277-289 Woodpark Road, Smithfield
Mason Stankovic Modification
Application for 277-289 Woodpark Road, Smithfield
Emma Hansma Modification
Application for 277-289 Woodpark Road, Smithfield
The Chairperson enquired to those
present in the Zoom call whether there were any further persons who would like
to address the Panel and no further persons presented themselves.
The open session of the meeting
here closed at 1:00p.m.
The closed session of the meeting here opened at 1:20p.m.
|
ITEM LPP003/21 - Development Application for
40-42 Ettalong Road, Greystanes
|
|
1.
That Development Application No. DA2020/0292 for Demolition of
existing structures and construction of a two storey 76 place childcare
centre over basement car parking on land at 40-42 Ettalong Road Greystanes
NSW 2145 be approved subject to the recommended conditions of consent in the
report as amended by the Panel:
a. An
Operational Management Plan being submitted for approval by the Executive
Manager Development and Building that addresses.
i.
Drop off and pick up of children;
ii.
How management will administer the use of the basement parking
to encourage parents to use it and not park on the street.
Reason:
To better protect the amenity of the neighbourhood.
2.
Amendment to condition 49 to include the word “northern
and eastern elevations”. The Council is to amend the consent condition
prior to issue.
3.
Addition to Condition 4 to read: “The fence that is
already erected partly on the neighbour’s land at 36 Ettalong Road
shall be removed and replaced by a fence wholly within the subject
site.”
4.
The landscape plan to be amended by omitting reference to the
planting of blueberry ash trees adjacent to 6 Hickory Street and their
replacement will be with an appropriate smaller species.
5.
Persons whom have lodged a submission in respect to the
application be notified of the determination of the application.
For:
The Hon. Paul Stein AM QC (Chairperson), Marjorie Ferguson, Michael
Ryan, and Allan Ezzy AM APM.
Against:
Nil.
Reasons
for Decision:
The Panel generally agrees with the Planning Officer’s
report but has added a number of conditions to mitigate amenity impacts on
the neighbourhood including the surrounding road network.
|
|
ITEM LPP004/21 -
Development Application for 67 Pegler Avenue, South Granville
|
|
1. That
Development Application No. DA2020/0423 for Demolition of existing structures
and construction of a three storey boarding house comprising 24 boarding
rooms and a manager's room over basement car parking on land at 67 Pegler
Avenue SOUTH GRANVILLE NSW 2142 be approved as deferred
commencement consent subject to attached listed conditions in Attachment 1.
2. Persons
whom have lodged a submission in respect to the application be notified of
the determination of the application.
For:
The Hon. Paul Stein AM QC (Chairperson), Marjorie Ferguson, Michael
Ryan, and Allan Ezzy AM APM.
Against:
Nil.
Reasons
for Decision:
The Panel
generally agrees with the Planning Officer’s report.
|
|
ITEM LPP005/21 -
Modification Application for 25-28 Joyce Street, Pendle Hill
|
|
1. That
Modification Application MOD2020/0296 being a Section 4.55(2) modification to
reconfigure the internal layout of apartments, alter floor levels, increase
height of building to facilitate lift overrun and associated rooftop
facilities, introduce rooftop communal open space and facade and built form
amendments on land at 25-28 Joyce Street Pendle Hill be approved subject to
attached conditions.
2. Persons
whom have lodged a submission in respect to the application be notified of
the determination of the application.
For:
The Hon. Paul Stein AM QC (Chairperson), Marjorie Ferguson, Michael
Ryan, and Allan Ezzy AM APM.
Against:
Nil.
Reasons
for Decision:
The Panel
agrees with the Planning Officer’s report.
|
|
ITEM LPP006/21 -
Modification Application for 277-289 Woodpark Road, Smithfield
|
|
1.
That Modification Application MOD2020/0147 being a Section
4.55(2) modification to extend the operating hours to allow for additional
manufacturing operation, truck and forklift movements and alter the site
layout to improve site functionality and vehicular movements, including the
reduction of on-site parking on land at 277-289 Woodpark Road Smithfield be
approved subject to attached conditions listed in the attached schedule as
amended by the Panel:
a. Condition
66 is amended as follows “ISO tanker unloading area shall be
Monday to Friday: 7:00am to 7:00pm, Saturday: 7:00am to 6:00pm and Sunday and
Public Holidays: no work permitted.”
b. “Bulk
powder truck deliveries including use of the wash bay area and cardboard
compacter shall be Monday to Saturday: 7:00am to 6:00pm and Sunday and Public
Holidays: No work permitted.”
2. Persons
whom have lodged a submission in respect to the application be notified of the
determination of the application.
For:
The Hon. Paul Stein AM QC (Chairperson), Marjorie Ferguson, Michael
Ryan, and Allan Ezzy AM APM.
Against:
Nil.
Reasons
for Decision:
The Panel
agrees with the Planning Officer’s report. The Panel also notes the
approval of the Environment Protection Authority and its recent issue of a
new licence.
|
|
ITEM LPP007/21 -
Development Application for 9-15 Raphael Street and Laneway 429, Lidcombe
|
|
That Development Application
No. DA2020/0461 for Construction of a 12 storey mixed use development with 5
level basement car parking, comprising ground floor commercial and
residential units above including landscaping, associated site works and site
amalgamation of 9-15 Raphael Street, Lidcombe with land known as Laneway 429;
on land at 9-15 Raphael Street and Laneway 429, LIDCOMBE be approved as
deferred commencement consent subject to conditions listed in Attachment 1 as
amended by the Panel as follows:
2.
DADCZ01
- Amended Building Height
Amended architectural plans are to be provided to
Council demonstrating compliance with the maximum building height standard of
32 metres, as prescribed by the Auburn Local Environmental Plan 2010. In this
regard, the following amendments shall be made to bring the proposal in line
with
the maximum 32m building height standard:
·
Levels 10 and 11 be deleted in their entirety;
·
The deletion of all 8 residential apartments on Level 9; and
·
The conversion of Level 9 to communal open space in the form
of a roof top terrace.
The ground floor and unit
mix of Levels 1-8 (inclusive) are to remain unchanged.
(Reason: To ensure compliance with the maximum
building height)
3. DADCZ02 - Amended
BASIX Certificate
An amended BASIX Certificate corresponding with the
revised number of dwellings, based on the deletion of all residential
apartments on Levels 9, 10 and 11 shall be submitted.
(Reason: Legislative requirement)
For:
The Hon. Paul Stein AM QC (Chairperson), Marjorie Ferguson, Michael
Ryan, and Allan Ezzy AM APM.
Against:
Nil.
Reasons
for Decision:
The Panel
agrees with the Planning Officer’s report.
|
|
ITEM LPP008/21 - Development
Application for Shop 2/203-211 Merrylands Road, Merrylands
|
|
1.
That Development Application DA-2020/0617 for use and fit out
of an existing shop as a bakery on land at Shop 2/203-211 Merrylands Road,
Merrylands be approved as a deferred commencement consent subject to the
recommended conditions as outlined within the report.
For:
The Hon. Paul Stein AM QC (Chairperson), Marjorie Ferguson, Michael
Ryan, and Allan Ezzy AM APM.
Against:
Nil.
Reasons
for Decision:
The Panel agrees with the
Planning Officer’s report.
|
The meeting terminated at 2:42pm.
Signed:
The Hon. Paul Stein AM QC
Chairperson